撰文:八爪魚家長 梁永樂先生
小一自行分配學位報名已告截止,家長「買定離手」只好聽天由命,現時至放榜期間的一段日子,於政府派位制度下唯一可做就是「呆等」。仍有小部分直資和私立學校接受報名,不甘心準備參與統一派位大抽獎的家長,可盡力一試直資和私立學校,而且坊間有不少網頁都有關於自資和私立的報名截止時間的列表。至於已報讀直資和私立學校的學生家長,尤其是大包圍的家長,現時全力籌劃密集式面試之餘,筆者亦不得不提醒家長要以孩子的心理健康為最優先考慮。
密集式面試殘害孩子心理
人類總是愛重複犯錯,每年 9 至 10 月面試高峰期剛過去,社會上都有不少有心人和關懷孩子心理健康的機構提醒,勿讓密集式面試殘害孩子的心理。以筆者記憶所及,最驚嚇的報紙標題是「難抵密集式升小一面試 5 歲女童抑鬱想跳樓」。小小5、6 歲人兒,仍不知道小學生活是怎樣的一回事,學校優劣是否名校,全因為家長的形容「這間是名校,但入了另一間就『大鑊』」等等,令孩子不明所以,於是產生沉重壓力。曾有精神科醫生或團體調查,不少孩子因此出現抑鬱及焦慮症病徵,兼有尋死念頭,需即時接受治療。
鬱悶在心有口難言
猶記得當日做記者的年代,筆者訪問資深校長、精神科醫生,部分孩子性格比較內向和慢熱,在最忙時,可能一天走幾場面試,與大批陌生校長和老師恭恭敬敬地玩遊戲,扮用心對答,事後家長又反覆追問「遊戲、對答」的內容,甚至無端端被罵或指導回答內容,一時間難免無法承受。
Written by: Octopus Parent, Mr. Leung Wing Lok
The registration for Primary One discretionary places has closed, and parents who have “bought and left” can only resign themselves to fate. During the period from now until the release of the allocation results, the only thing that can be done under the government’s school allocation system is to “wait idly.” There are still a small number of Direct Subsidy Scheme (DSS) and private schools accepting applications. Parents who are unwilling to participate in the lottery for the central allocation can try their luck with DSS and private schools. Moreover, there are many websites that list the application deadlines for self-financed and private schools. For parents of students who have already applied to DSS and private schools, especially those who are preparing intensively for interviews, I must remind parents to prioritize their children’s mental health.
Intensive interviews harm children’s psychology
Humans always tend to repeat mistakes. Every year, after the peak period of interviews in September and October has passed, there
are many well-intentioned people and organizations concerned with children’s mental health reminding us not to let intensive interviews harm children’s psychology. From what I remember, the most shocking newspaper headline was “Unable to withstand the intensive interviews for Primary One, a 5-year-old girl becomes depressed and wants to jump off a building.” These young children, only 5 or 6 years old, still do not understand what primary school life is about, nor do they know the difference between good and bad schools. It’s all because of how parents describe them, saying “This is a prestigious school, but if you get into another one, it’s a disaster,” and so on, leaving the children confused and thus under immense pressure. There have been investigations by psychiatrists or groups showing that many children have developed symptoms of depression and anxiety, including suicidal thoughts, and need immediate treatment.
Depression that cannot be voiced
I remember, during my days as a journalist, interviewing veteran principals and psychiatrists. Some children, especially those who are more introverted and slow to warm up, might go through several interviews in a day during the busiest times. They play games and answer questions respectfully in front of a large number of unfamiliar principals and teachers. Afterwards, parents repeatedly ask about the content of the “games and answers,” and even scold or instruct them on how to respond without any reason, making it inevitable for some to be unable to bear it.
筆者自己成為家長後,更加緊記著該精神科醫生所言,家長不單要留意孩子的生活習慣轉變,例如忽然對平日愛好失去興趣,看電視、讀書和玩具,全部放在一邊等等不正常改變,更重要是家長應留意自己的改變,家長有否因為替孩子準備履歷表和緊張面試,而在家變身成為「Hulk」 般長期憤怒狀態,或者與孩子講故事、玩耍和放假戶外活動等等親子活動全部暫停。試問家長變升小一怪獸,孩子怎可能獨善其身呢?
家長尤其請緊記,孩子只有5 至6歲,仍未懂得表達心中的鬱悶及壓力,甚至不捨得向父母發脾氣,鬱在心裡口難開。即使不至於心理病,萬一親子關係破裂,也再難修復。親子之間的信任就像紙張,當你把它弄皺後,你永遠都不能再把它回復原狀。
本篇比較苦口婆心,筆者不知道顧及孩子升小的心理變化算不算是選校策略或貼士,只知道家長總會緊張孩子的前途,但請記得當孩子出生時,經常掛在口邊對孩子的期許是:「健康快樂成長,做個有用的人就足夠了」,但當小一前途問題的考慮來臨,你有忘記初衷嗎?
After becoming a parent myself, I have become even more mindful of what the psychiatrist said. Parents should not only pay attention to changes in their children’s daily habits, such as suddenly losing interest in their usual hobbies like watching TV, reading, and playing with toys—all of which are abnormal changes. More importantly, parents should be aware of their own changes. Have parents, in the process of preparing resumes and getting nervous about interviews, turned into a ‘Hulk’ at home, constantly in a state of anger, or have they put a halt to parent-child activities such as storytelling, playing, and outdoor activities during holidays? If parents transform into Primary One monsters, how can children possibly remain unaffected?
Parents, please remember, children are only 5 to 6 years old and still do not know how to express the depression and pressure in their hearts. They may even be reluctant to show anger towards their parents, keeping their feelings bottled up inside. Even if it doesn’t lead to psychological illness, if the parent-child relationship is broken, it can be very difficult to repair. The trust between parent and child is like a piece of paper; once you crumple it, you can never return it to its original state.
This article may sound a bit preachy, and I don’t know
if considering the psychological changes in children when choosing a school
counts as a strategy or tip. I only know that parents are always anxious about
their children’s future, but please remember the wish you often expressed when
your child was born: “To grow up healthy and happy, and to become a useful
person is enough.” But when faced with considerations for Primary One,
have you forgotten your original intention?